MEDICAL SUPPORT
CS 494P Contesting a National Medical
Support Notice
01/23/03 Revised 09/09/24 Training Completed
09/23/24 Last Reviewed 07/10/25
45
CFR 303.32; 42
U.S.C. 666(a)(19); Utah Code 26B-9-225; R527-201
Noncustodial Parent/Custodial Parent Options After National
Medical Support Notice
The National Medical Support Notice (NMSN) must result in
the dependent child(ren) being enrolled in an insurance plan, unless the noncustodial
parent (NCP)/custodial parent (CP) successfully
contests the notice based on a mistake of fact.
Utah Code
26B-9-225 states:
“(2) The
office shall provide concurrent notice to the parent or legal guardian in
accordance with Section 26B-9-207 of:
(a)
the notice to enroll sent to the employer or union; and
(b)
the opportunity to contest the
enrollment due to a mistake of fact by filing a written request for an
adjudicative proceeding with the office within 15 days of the notice being
sent.” (Emphasis Added)
After the NMSN is received by the employer, the NCP/CP has two options available as follows:
1.
Do nothing and allow the NMSN to proceed; or,
2.
Contest the NMSN based
on a mistake of fact.
a.
42 U.S.C. 666(a)(19)(C) states:
“any liability of the noncustodial
parent to such plan for employee contributions which are required under such
plan for enrollment of the child is effectively subject to appropriate
enforcement, unless the noncustodial parent contests such enforcement based on
a mistake of fact.”
b.
45 CFR 303.32(c)(5) states:
“Employees
may contest the withholding based on a mistake of fact. If the employee
contests such withholding, the employer must initiate withholding until such
time as the employer receives notice that the contest is resolved.”
NOTE: If the CP objects to an NMSN because s/he was
not a “party” to the original judicial action (judicial order), and feels s/he
has no legal responsibility to carry health insurance until the order is
amended, contact the Attorney General’s Office (AGO) or the ORS management
chain immediately for further guidance.
Contesting a National Medical Support Notice
R527-201-9 states:
“(7) In accordance with
Subsections 26B-9-225(2) and (3), the parent may contest withholding health
insurance premiums based on a mistake of fact.
The employer shall continue withholding under the NMSN until notified by
ORS to terminate withholding health insurance premiums.”
There may be reasons other than “mistake of fact” why the NMSN
action is inappropriate, such as:
1.
The
NCP/CP previously provided CSS with written proof of enrollment in accordance with the order. Gather the insurance information
and add it to ORSIS.
a.
If the NCP/CP already has insurance coverage
for the child(ren) and provides proof of that coverage, complete the following:
i.
Terminate the NMSN by sending the
Insurance: Notice to Terminate form to
the employer;
ii.
Send a copy of the form to the parent
providing the insurance; and,
iii.
Create a case narrative documenting the reason
why the form was sent.
NOTE : When sending a copy of the termination form
to the NCP, generate and send the form without the child(ren)’s social security
number.
2.
Insurance coverage is not available at group rates through the NCP/CP’s
employer. The employer
should notify CSS by completing and sending in the Employer Response form. If you have not received that information
from the employer, call and confirm that
information; i.e., verify that the employer does not offer insurance to any
of its employees.
3.
The
total cost of the NCP/CP’s share of the monthly insurance premium has been
deemed by CSS to be unreasonable in cost.
Senior agents should make a reasonable cost determination only if the
NCP/CP requests it through the Written Request for Review National Medical
Support Notice.
4.
The total cost of the NCP/CP’s share of the monthly insurance
premium would exceed the maximum allowable limits.
·
The employer notifies CSS that they are
currently withholding money to satisfy a child support obligation and the
inclusion of a monthly insurance premium amount will cause them to exceed
Consumer Credit Protection Act (CCPA) limits; or,
·
A parent(s) on a CIC case who has received
adoption assistance for a child in the care or custody of the state provides
certification from the employer or insurance company that insuring the child
would exceed the maximum allowable benefits.
NOTE: Due to the special needs of many children who
receive adoption assistance, e.g., extensive counseling, medication, and
treatment for psychological disorders, the cost of providing medical and dental
insurance for a child who is or was receiving adoption assistance could
potentially be unreasonable and, as a result, could max-out the allowable
insurance benefits for the remaining individuals covered under the insurance
policy.
5.
Insurance
is not accessible to the child(ren). Non-emergency
services covered by the health plan are not accessible to the child(ren) within
90 minutes or 90 miles of the child’s primary residence.
After
confirming that the insurance is not accessible to the child(ren) because they
reside more than 90 miles or 90 minutes from where non-emergency services
covered by the health plan are available,
6.
A modification to the child support order no longer requires the
parent to maintain insurance for the child(ren).
7.
The child(ren) is legally emancipated.
Administrative Review Procedures
The NCP/CP
may contest a NMSN by requesting an “administrative review.” An administrative review is outside the
formal RAA/UAPA process and gives the NCP/CP the option to try to resolve
disputed issues informally with CSS.
The administrative review must be made within 15 days of receiving the request for review.
NOTE: An administrative
review of the NMSN can be made at anytime following the initial 15 day period
if the circumstances have changed AND with manager approval. For example:
A NMSN is sent and a review based on unreasonable cost is
completed. The cost is found to be
reasonable so the NMSN remains in place.
A year later the NCP/CP requests another review because his/her monthly
insurance premium cost has increased substantially. With the request for a review AND manager
approval, another review may be conducted based on the change of
circumstance.
If an
administrative review is requested, the
designated Senior Agent will conduct the review to try and resolve the
issue(s) informally. The Senior Agent
must complete the review as soon as possible by taking all of the steps listed below.
1.
Determine
the case in dispute. If the NCP/CP has more
than one IV-D case, determine the appropriate case (or cases). If more than one case is involved, handle the review for each case separately.
2.
Review
the case(s) actions. During the administrative
review, the employer must continue to withhold insurance premiums under the
NMSN, unless CSS terminates the Notice.
3.
Confirm
the National Medical Support Notice. Confirm that:
a.
The child support order requires the NCP/CP to provide
medical insurance for the child(ren);
b.
Insurance was available to the NCP/CP through his/her
employment at a group rate 30 days prior to the date of mailing the notice;
and,
c.
The children were not already enrolled in a medical
insurance plan.
4.
Gather
evidence. The NCP/CP must provide
CSS with written evidence to support his/her claim. If the evidence is not received within 30
days, proceed with the review and make a determination based on the available
facts and evidence.
The NCP/CP does not need to appear in person to provide and/or dispute
evidence, but may choose to appear in the office. If the “Request for Review: National Medical
Support Notice” has been marked to indicate that the NCP/CP wants to appear in
person at the review, send the “Request for Review Appointment Letter” to
him/her. If an attorney has been
retained, s/he may also attend the review.
5.
Make
a determination. Review the available facts
and evidence and determine if the NCP/CP’s claims are valid.
6.
Generate
the “Determination Notice”.
a.
Generate and send the “Response to Request for Review: NMSN” to
the NCP/CP along with the “Written Request for Review: NMSN”, to allow the
NCP/CP the opportunity to request an adjudicative proceeding.
NOTE: When/if you review more than one case for the
NCP, generate forms for each case. Send
the notice(s) by first-class mail.
The form gives the NCP/CP:
i.
the results of the administrative review; and,
ii.
explains the options for appeal.
The NCP/CP may appeal the decision by making a written request for an
adjudicative proceeding or by filing a court action. For more information on both these options,
refer to the appropriate corresponding section below.
b.
Mail the documents to the NCP/CP by first-class mail.
7.
Take
the appropriate follow-up action.
Depending on the outcome of the review, take the next appropriate
follow-up action; e.g., update ORSIS and the medical screens, send any new or
modified forms that may be necessary based on the determination, which may
include sending a new NMSN or terminating the NMSN. R527-201-9 states:
“(8) If a parent
successfully contests the action to enroll the children in a health insurance
plan based on a mistake of fact, ORS shall notify the employer to discontinue
enrollment and withholding health insurance premiums for the children.”
8.
Write
a case narrative. Write a detailed narrative
for each case you reviewed. Include the
determination and all of the actions taken on the case(s).
Adjudicative Proceeding Procedures
The NCP/CP may request an adjudicative proceeding under UAPA
within 15 days of receiving the NMSN
or within 15 days of receiving the “Response to Request for Review: NMSN.” If an adjudicative proceeding is requested,
the responsible agent or Presiding Officer (PO) is responsible to complete the
following:
1.
Review
the case for appropriate collection and enforcement actions. During the review time period, the
employer must continue withholding insurance premiums, unless CSS terminates
the National Medical Support Notice.
2.
Compile
the state’s evidence. Gather the facts and
evidence from the CSS case narratives and any necessary documents from Content
Manager records and present it to the PO.
3.
Presiding
Officer responsibilities.
a.
Confirm
the National Medical Support Notice. Confirm that:
i.
The child support order requires the
NCP/CP to provide medical insurance for the child(ren);
ii.
Insurance was available to the NCP/CP through his/her
employment at a group rate 30 days prior to the date of mailing the notice;
and,
iii.
The children were not already enrolled in a medical
insurance plan.
b.
Gather the NCP/CP/s evidence.
The NCP/CP must provide written evidence to support his/her
claim. If you do not receive the
evidence within 30 days from the date of the request, proceed with the review
and make a determination based on the available facts and evidence.
If the NCP/CP marks the “Request for Review: National Medical Support Notice”,
send the “Request for Review Appointment Letter”. The “Request for Review Appointment Letter”
informs the NCP/CP of the date and time of the review. If an attorney has been retained, s/he may
also appear.
c.
Notify
the other party and gather the other party’s evidence, if appropriate. Send the “Notice of Adjudicative
Proceeding: NMSN” or the “Noncustodial Parent Notice of Adjudicative
Proceeding: NMSN” to the other party by first class mail. The notice informs the other party of the
proposed action and invites him/her to present his/her own evidence or
documentation. The notice is optional on
IV-A cases and is not required on Children in Care (CIC) cases.
The other party does not need to appear in person to present or dispute their
evidence or documentation, but may choose to appear with the contesting party
or separately, to present evidence and/or review and dispute the other party’s
evidence. If an attorney has been
retained, s/he may also appear at the review.
d.
Make
a determination and issue a Decision and Order.
i.
Review all of the facts and evidence presented by the agent, the
requesting party, and the other party to make a determination.
ii.
Generate and issue the appropriate Decision and Order for each
case, as listed below.
A.
NCP: “Decision and Order:
Adjudicative Proceeding, NMSN, Noncustodial Parent”.
B.
CP: “Decision and Order:
Adjudicative Proceeding, NMSN, Custodial Parent”.
The
Decision and Order notifies the NCP/CP of the adjudicative proceeding decision
and of his/her options for appeal. The NCP/CP
may request reconsideration of the Decision and Order or file a court
action. For more information on both of
these options, refer to the appropriate corresponding sections below.
e.
Process
the Decision and Order.
i.
Sign and date the order.
The order allows the NCP/CP 20 days to request reconsideration of the
determination. Include the “Decision and Order Cover Letter”.
ii.
Mail by first class mail or deliver a copy of the order personally
to the NCP/CP. Include the “Decision and
Order Cover Letter”.
iii.
Mail by first class mail a copy of the order to the other
party. Include the “Courtesy Copy of
Administrative Order”.
iv.
Mail by first class mail a copy of the order to the:
A.
NCP/CP’s attorney if s/he is represented by legal counsel; and/or,
B.
the initiating state on an incoming interstate case.
f.
Take
the appropriate follow-up actions. Depending on the outcome of the
review, take the next appropriate follow-up action; e.g., update ORSIS and the
appropriate medical screens, send any new or modified forms that may be necessary
based on the determination, which may include sending a new NMSN or terminating
a NMSN. R527-201-9 states:
“(8)
If a parent successfully contests the action to enroll the children in a health insurance
plan based on a mistake of fact, ORS shall notify the employer to discontinue
enrollment and withholding health insurance premiums for the children.”
g.
Write
a case narrative. Document the rationale
used for making the decision based on the facts and evidence and any follow-up
action taken on the case.
A Decision
and Order that has been issued by CSS is subject to reconsideration if the
NCP/CP makes a written request within 20 days after the Decision and Order was
issued.
Reconsideration Procedures
Decision and Orders
that have been issued by CSS are subject to reconsideration if a written
request is made in within 20 days of issuing the Decision and Order. A reconsideration request does not have a
specific form, but must be in writing
and must state specific grounds upon which relief is requested.
If you
receive a request for reconsideration, forward the request to the Presiding
Officer responsible for the Decision and Order.
The PO is responsible for taking the steps listed below.
1.
Review
the case for appropriate actions.
During the review period the employer must continue withholding
insurance premiums under the, unless CSS terminates the National Medical
Support Notice.
2.
Grant
or deny the reconsideration request.
a.
Deny
Reconsideration: If
you deny the request for reconsideration, complete the following:
i.
Issue the “Order: RAA Reconsideration Denied”. Sign and date the order.
ii.
Mail a copy of the order to the NCP/CP and the other party. Include the “Courtesy Copy of Administrative
Order”.
NOTE: The ORDN provides the NCP/CP with information
about his/her options for appeal.
b.
Grant
Reconsideration: If
you grant the request for reconsideration, complete the following:
i.
Issue the “Order: RAA Reconsideration Granted”/“Order: RAA Reconsideration Granted”.
ii.
Review the facts and evidence of the case, as well as any new
pertinent information received from the applicant/recipient.
iii.
Issue the “Order Based on Reconsideration: Non-cooperation”. The “Order Based on Reconsideration:
Non-cooperation” affirms or amends the original “Decision and Order”.
NOTE: A conference may be conducted to facilitate
full reconsideration.
iv.
Mail by first class mail or deliver a copy of the order personally
to the NCP/CP.
v.
Mail by first class mail a copy of the order to the other party. Include the “Custodial Parent Notice of
Reconsideration” or the “Noncustodial Parent Notice of Reconsideration”. This notice informs the other party that
reconsideration has been granted and invites the other party to present any new
or additional information.
The NCP and CP are not required to appear in person to present the new
evidence, but they may choose to appear, separately or together, to review and
dispute each other’s evidence.
vi.
Mail by first class mail a copy of the order to the:
A.
NCP/CP’s attorney if s/he is represented by legal counsel; and/or
send,
B.
the initiating state on an incoming interstate case.
c.
Neither
Grant nor Deny Reconsideration: If
the request for reconsider is not granted or denied with 20 days, the request
is considered denied and the original Decision and Order stands.
3.
Take
the appropriate follow-up actions.
Depending on the outcome of the review, take the next appropriate
follow-up action; e.g., update ORSIS and the medical screens, send any new or
modified forms that may be necessary based on the determination, which may
include sending a new NMSN or terminating a NMSN. R527-201-9
states:
“(8)
If a parent successfully contests the action to enroll the children in a health
insurance plan based on a mistake of fact, ORS shall notify the employer to
discontinue enrollment and withholding health insurance premiums for the
children.”
4.
Write
a case narrative. Document all the actions
taken on the case(s) and the reason(s) for those actions.
If the NCP/CP
wants to appeal the reconsideration decision or the new order based on
reconsideration, s/he may file a court action.
Reconsideration is not a prerequisite for a court action.
Procedures Court Action Filed
The NCP/CP may choose to file his/her
own court action instead of, or in addition to, requesting an administrative
review or an adjudicative proceeding.
The NCP/CP must provide CSS with evidence that an action has been filed.
The evidence of the filing will generally be notice
of the legal pleadings. Once you are
notified of the filing, send a referral packet to the Attorney General’s Office
(AGO).